Everyone will have there opinions and preferences about designs and interactions. Sometimes when you have competing approaches you may have to go through some studies. But nonetheless, you should make decisions based upon all relevant factors, not just aesthetic. These factors could be based upon what your target customers may be used to, capabilities of the device, future-proofing, business objectives, etc.
A creative director with a history of successfully bringing products to market and usage. An award-winning, patent-holding, innovative thinking, results-focused
creative with experience in leading teams to a wide range of internal and external product design experiences and systems design.